Mario's Pizzeria of Oyster Bay

253 Pine Hollow Rd, Oyster Bay, NY 11771 Order now
Hero image

Family Owned and Operated Since 1969


Our reviews

Reviews from Grubhub

Mario's Pizzeria of Oyster Bay Reviews on Grubhub


Top Reviewer
Order arrived hot and fresh earlier than the estimated time! Staff was extremely helpful when I called them to add something and they didn't even charge me. Definitely the best pizza in town. Always consistent.


1 review
I've been going here for years, and it just as amazing as my first visit. Great food, great atmosphere and staff, and delivery is always fast, efficient, and


Top Reviewer
Quickest delivery in town. Food comes from the oven right to your door. I order here every other night. Great food great people.


Top Reviewer
Delicious food and even came earlier than predicted. Delivery guy was nice. Will definitely order from again.


Top Reviewer
The food was and is always amazing!! Best pizza place in town. Grandmas lie is hands down the best choice!

Reviews from

Mario's Pizzeria of Oyster Bay Reviews on Seamless


Top Reviewer
Very good pizza. My parents werehappy to get pizza delivery.


Top Reviewer
Always hot, always good, always on time or earlier :)


Top Reviewer
Never disappointed- get the chicken penne pesto


Top Reviewer
Food was yummy and delivery boy was very kind


Top Reviewer
Thanks for delivering in the snow!

About us

Dinner, Lunch Specials, Pizza
Delivery: 11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
Takeout: 11:00 AM - 9:30 PM

Marios Pizzeria opened its first pizzeria in Oyster Bay, a hamlet on the north shore of Long Island in 1969. Since then the entire family has been providing the highest quality meals with exceptional service in a fast casual dining experience for over 45 years. How do we know its the best? You, Our Loyal customers have told us over the years with the many reviews and feedback. From Oyster Bay, Syosset, Plainview, Westbury, Seaford and Great Neck, Marios has become a household name that offers online ordering and convenience to our many customers with fast and reliable delivery service that covers practically all of Nassau County. Every pizza is handmade from scratch with dough and sauce that is made fresh daily with care and special attention. From pioneering "pizza by the slice" with an extensive variety of gourmet pizzas using the finest quality ingredients to serving our communities with sponsorships and donations, we continue to define what a great Long Island pizzeria should be. But we are more than a "Pizza Place". Marios is a family. Through the years our dedicated staff has grown yet we are proud to say that a majority of our employees now have their own families working with us. They have become a part of our family as we look forward to spending many milestones with them. Our main goal is to commit to quality, listen to our customers and keep them happy so that we can continue to improve. We welcome you to come experience what all our customers are saying. Place your order today, let us do the rest!